BENEFIT 254: If a [Salafi] scholar, who has made mistakes in matters of Aqeedah or manhaj, is still in the process of being advised, should we refrain from taking knowledge from him as long as he is i
Sheikh Yūsuf Al-Jazaa’iri hafidahullāh:
The errors made by scholars in matters of Aqeedah, we need to know that there matters which are considered Usool (fundamentals). Some issues are clear and fundamental, and the truth regarding them is evident. If a scholar errs in such matters, the proof has already been established against him, and he is declared an innovator for opposing the clear truth. For instance, if a…
"9. The publicising and manifesting the seeking mercy for Ubaid Al-Jaabiri; who is a person of Innovation and a staunch Hizbi isn't correct, in such a public setting for no apparent reason which makes it a must. Is not correct and it is to be avoided." [End Quote]
RESPONSE:
Ruling on seeking Mercy for the People of Innovation (1)
Question: Is it prohibited to seek mercy upon the people of innovation, whether in…
Sheikh ’Uthaymeen raḥimahullāh said:
"The causes of error are three: lack of knowledge, limited understanding, and ill intent. The first two involve a deficiency in knowledge or understanding. A person may have limited knowledge, or they may possess knowledge but lack the capacity to understand it. Many people have vast knowledge, yet they fail to comprehend it correctly. The third cause is ill intent: a person may…
"6. At-Tahiri's conveying greetings and sending regards when he was told about studying with some of the students from Dammaj, which was from the reasons which lead to have a favourable opinion of At-Tahiri..." [end quote]
RESPONSE:
The fact that Sheikh At-Tahiri conveyed greetings and sent regards upon hearing about studying with students from Dammaj is, in fact, a positive and praiseworthy action, not a cause…
"Also,Tahiri is either unaware of the mistakes of Ubaid and what took place of the refutations against him and the extensive list of observations against him, and unaware that a Fitnah took place in Yemen and that not everyone who was in Dammaj at one point is upright. Or he is aware as is being eluded to in point 6..." [end quote]
RESPONSE:
Whether he was aware of all the observations or not, I don't know, but…
"5. Using the speech of Shaykh Yahya Hafidhahullah and Shaykh Fawzaan Hafidhahullah, on the subject matter of Tabdee. This a reoccurring misunderstanding, Tabdee is not the only reason for stopping the taking knowledge from a person, or to not promote a person to the masses, so it's not correct to tie it to this, and bring up this topic everytime someone is advised against..." [end of quote]
RESPONSE:
This is…
"4. Relying on statements relayed by certain individuals, whilst not contacting At-Tahiri directly for these things. Whilst it's possible he can be contacted, as will be the case when it's time to deliver the lectures, this is something strange." [end of quote]
RESPONSE:
This point has already been addressed ⤵️
https://t.me/almanhajussalafi/882
"3. Regarding the companionship which was supposedly severed and ended with a warning. What's under question is the position of At-Tahiri towards Ubaid, not the other way round, and brushing this away due to the warning of Ubaid of At-Tahiri; which doesn't nullify this affair, isn't appropriate and Allah knows best, especially as there are still clear signs of deep inclination towards Ubaid, until after his death.…
"2. This putting the poetry of Al-Halabi forth as a benefit was coupled by At-Tahiri calling Al-Halabi a Shaykh in a video which has been spread far and wide on the internet for a number of years. The praise and benefiting from Al-Halabi now is public, so if this is now incorrect, the clarification should also be made public. So it reaches those people the first affair reached." [end quote]
RESPONSE:
In situations…
"1. In the relaying of the first observation against At-Tahiri, there is no mention of him calling Ali bin Hassan Al-Halabi a Shaykh alongside using his poetry as a point of benefit. When relaying an affair it's required to be relayed correctly and precisely, so the reader won't be suprised lateron with a difference in what took place, which will bring about bad thoughts of you." [end quote]
RESPONSE:
Abu Atiyyah…
THE WRITER STATES:
"If only this speech (referring to Abu Atiyyah's clarification) was sent in private as the questioning took place in private before putting it out in public. I tried to contact our brothers in private through you akhi Abu Maryam, in order to send our brothers the speech of the Mashaayikh, namely the speech of Shaykh Abdulghani and Shaykh Mansuur and Shaykh Najeeb...But as you made this public in…
She comes and goes without knowing the difference between a Salafi and a Hizbi!
Question: A woman states that she studies at Salafi centres while her siblings study at Hizbi masjids. She asks what is the difference between Salafees and Hizbees?
Sheikh ’Abdulḥamīd Az-Zu'kari ḥafidhahullāh:
In that case, perhaps she just enters and exits the Salafi centres [without understanding]. There are many differences:…
Sheikh ’Abdullāh ibn Lamḥ Al-Khawlāni ḥafidhahullāh wrote:
الشيخ أبو عطية من طلاب العلم المجتهدين الذين نفع الله بهم نحسبه كذلك والله حسيبه وفقه الله وسدده، ومن وفق للخير والاستفادة من إخوانه بدون مقارنات وتنقص فنعما هو،
ولكن فديت جسدا بلا حسد
فمن رأى أنه أرفع فليرحل إلى من يراه عالما يدرس عنده ولا يكون قاطع طريق على طلاب العلم فيهلك.
قال الله {وتذوقوا السوء بما صددتم عن سبيل الله}
فننصح إخواننا بالتواضع ولين…
As for his participation in a conference with Faisal Al-Jaasim, one of our distinguished students, Isa Al-Bashawiri, may Allāh grant him success, provided the following clarification:
"The Sheikh's position is one of disagreement with Faisal regarding the issues that have he has been criticised for over the past few years. One of the Sheikh's closest students, who is also one of my teachers, informed me privately that the Sheikh's attendance at the conference with Faisal was due to a request from some senior officials in the Kuwaiti Ministry of Religious Endowments. Although the Sheikh was…
"After all of this, Sheikh Ubaid Al-Jabiri (may Allāh forgive him) warned against studying under Dr. Abu Salah (Muhammad At-Tahiri)! This, by Allāh, is one of the consequences of tale-carrying which A
http://www.saltaweel.com/articles/344
This article was dated Sha’ban 14, 1435 AH, which means over a decade has passed since its publication, indicating that their separation and Sheikh Ubaid’s warning against him occurred even earlier. Where is this companionship, then, when it has been severed for over ten years and ended with a warning? It is not far-fetched to think that someone was tale-carrying about Sheikh…
I have received some inquiries regarding a telelink lecture arranged by some of our brothers with Sheikh Muhammad At-Tahiri (may Allāh grant him success to what pleases Him). Since certain concerns have been raised about him, and these inquiries come from noble and beloved brothers, whose requests are dear to me, I felt compelled to respond. However, answering each individual inquiry separately would take…
https://t.me/almanhajussalafi/870
وهذا تأصيل جيد ، وعليه أهل العلم، فقال الشيخ الفوزان مبينا متى يصح إلحاق من توقف عن تبديع المبتدع به فقال "لأنه أجاز البدعة ووافقه عليها"
https://dralfawzann.com/file/8166/
ومفهومه واضح، أن من لم يكن كذلك، فحكمه يختلف.و أتذكر في هذا المقام عندما نزل الشيخ السحيمي وفقه الله بريطانيا دعوة إلى الله عام 1439هـ، وسئل الشيخ يحيى أيده الله حول استقباله في مسجد مقبل والاستفادة منه. أجاب…
فقد بلغني بعض الاستفسارات حول محاضرة هاتفية نسقها بعض إخواننا مع الشيخ محمد الطاهري -وفقه الله لما فيه رضاه-، نظرا لأن عليه ملاحظات فحداني إلى البيان عما سألوا، مجيئها من إخوة محبين أفاضل طلبهم عزيز علي سددنا الله وإياهم وإجابة كل سائل على حدة تستغرق وقتاً ثميناً يعسر توفره مع كثرة القضايا الدعوية وغيرها.
فارتأيت الكتابة توفيرا للوقت وتسهيلا للأمر بإذن الله الرب، وبدأت بإلقاء نظرة متجردة على ما سُطر من الملاحظات…
Al-’Izz Ibn ’Abdis-Salām (D. 660H) said:
«وَالْغَالِب أن الْحَسَد لَا يَقع إِلَّا بَين المشتركين في فَضِيلَة من الْفَضَائِل أو فِي شَيْء من الْأَسْبَاب الدُّنْيَوِيَّة فَلَا يخسد الْفَقِيه النّخوِيَ وَلَا التَّاجِر الجمال وَلَا الصَّانع الْبَقَال ومن أسباب الْحَسَد التجاوز وَلذَلِك أمر عمر رَضِي الله تَعَالَى عنه الأقارب أن يتزاوروا وَلَا يتجاوروا»
"Envy typically arises between people who share a particular…
This channel does an excellent job of clarifying the destructive beliefs of the Sufis of Hadhramawt (Yemen). (*beware of the tasweer*)⤵️
https://t.me/sofiathadramout/7773
As a Ba Alawi, I believe that cautioning others about the Shirk of my ancestors can help lessen their burden, by preventing further misguidance.
{ لِیَحۡمِلُوۤا۟ أَوۡزَارَهُمۡ كَامِلَةࣰ یَوۡمَ ٱلۡقِیَـٰمَةِ وَمِنۡ أَوۡزَارِ ٱلَّذِینَ یُضِلُّونَهُم بِغَیۡرِ عِلۡمٍۗ أَلَا سَاۤءَ مَا یَزِرُونَ }
"They may bear their own burdens in full on the Day of Resurrection, and also of the…
